Post by soccerwizard18 on Jun 28, 2004 12:43:38 GMT -5
ok i think that the prophecy is not about harry or it is both about harry and neville...
i have many reasons....
but here is something i think about dumbledore
jkr has built up the reliance of everything dumbledore says... but what if this once he is wrong...i think he is...
well here is something else....in the shrieking shack sirius said that pettigrew woudlnt kill harry until voldemorte was back in power so then he would kill him and deliver the last potter
what was that ...last...so that means that that oculd be the reason...not the proophecy....and also voldedmorte killed james without thought..we think and didnt nececarily need to kill lily....
but i know it was never repeated but what if she juts broke her own rule to fool us?
so i think that neville isnt marked visably but he is marked!!
so i think the prophecy is either a red herring or it isnt half the reason voldemorte wants to kill harry!!!
so i think nevile is it or both hary and nevile..which i think the latter
( sorry i didnt have much time because i had to go...so i was typing as fast as i could....but do you contribute to peoples theorys on this board??i was jsut wondering because some only fix posts and dont ad in the conversations..not being rude...just wondering)
i have many reasons....
but here is something i think about dumbledore
jkr has built up the reliance of everything dumbledore says... but what if this once he is wrong...i think he is...
well here is something else....in the shrieking shack sirius said that pettigrew woudlnt kill harry until voldemorte was back in power so then he would kill him and deliver the last potter
what was that ...last...so that means that that oculd be the reason...not the proophecy....and also voldedmorte killed james without thought..we think and didnt nececarily need to kill lily....
but i know it was never repeated but what if she juts broke her own rule to fool us?
so i think that neville isnt marked visably but he is marked!!
so i think the prophecy is either a red herring or it isnt half the reason voldemorte wants to kill harry!!!
so i think nevile is it or both hary and nevile..which i think the latter
( sorry i didnt have much time because i had to go...so i was typing as fast as i could....but do you contribute to peoples theorys on this board??i was jsut wondering because some only fix posts and dont ad in the conversations..not being rude...just wondering)
